#574
Between Pension Pools and Political Potholes
Published:
Jan 18, 2025
Author:
Sarah Parsons Wolter
Share:
In the world of pensions, where long-term planning is paramount, short-term political maneuvers seem to be the order of the day. On one side of the Channel, UK councils are sparring with the government over “megafunds” that aim to centralize £392b of local pension assets. On the other, France’s new Prime Minister, François Bayrou, is gingerly hinting at undoing President Macron’s signature reform of raising the retirement age to 64. While the specifics of these battles differ, the underlying tension is the same: who should wield control over pension policy, and at what cost?
The UK government’s push for pension consolidation is pitched as a bid to reduce administrative costs and free up capital for infrastructure projects. But councils managing £145b of these assets have raised a valid concern: a mandatory reliance on advice from the pools managing their funds creates a fox-guarding-the-henhouse scenario. If accountability is diluted, the pools could end up grading their own homework, leaving councils—and, by extension, pensioners—vulnerable. The government promises local authorities will retain strategic oversight, but the devil is in the details. Can you claim local control when it’s shackled by mandated advice?
Meanwhile, in France, Bayrou’s olive branch to unions and leftist parties underscores the political perils of pension reform. Macron’s move to raise the retirement age sparked widespread protests and, ultimately, a legislative collapse. Bayrou’s attempt to renegotiate—a euphemism for rolling back—reflects the precarious balance between fiscal responsibility and political expediency. But his conundrum is no less thorny: appease unions and risk financial instability or uphold reforms and face parliamentary mutiny. The specter of France’s soaring debt-to-GDP ratio looms large, with Brussels watching closely and bond spreads creeping up ominously.
These pension reform debates take on an added dimension when viewed against private equity’s growing ambition to tap into retirement funds. Firms like Apollo and Blackstone are lobbying to access trillions in 401(k) savings in the U.S., promising new avenues for investment but raising concerns about transparency, liquidity, and fees. As governments struggle to modernize pension systems while maintaining accountability, private equity’s push reflects the high stakes of who controls retirement savings—a question just as relevant in the boardrooms of Apollo as it is in UK town halls or French parliaments.
Portfolio News
John Hancock Retirement announces partnership with Vestwell, launching FutureStep™ to expand plan offering - Vestwell's technology powers FutureStep by John Hancock Retirement, which will be available in early 2025. This offering is designed to help advisors scale their practices while providing a simple, modern interface for seamless interactions across the advisor, employer, and saver portals. Read more
Plaid’s revenue, usage rates jump as CEO sees ‘Fintech Spring’ - Revenue at Plaid, which provides the pipes fintechs and banks use to talk to each other, jumped more than 25% last year, as at least half of all US consumers encountered its technology in some way. While banks used to chafe at working with their fintech competitors, most have come around to the idea that partnering with Plaid and others like it can be beneficial as their customers go online for financial products. Read more
CapIntel celebrates successful rollout with Canada Life, paving the way for elevated client-advisor experiences - The relationship reinforces CapIntel’s commitment to delivering cutting-edge technology and seamless system-to-system integrations, with an interactive comparison and proposal tool that allows clients to better understand their investment portfolio. Read more
Innovate Finance: FinTech Investment Landscape 2024 - Gareth Jones is quoted in an informative report published by Innovate Finance on the current state of fintech, and outlook for the future. This report, which starts with the overarching question of have we reached the bottom yet and when will we start to see the upturn, provides the numbers and analysis behind the headlines, takes a deeper dive into the latest investment trends in global and UK FinTech, and offers an outlook for 2025. The analysis benefits from input and observations from Innovate Finance’s investor and VC members. Read more
Between Pension Pools and Political Potholes
New French PM opens door to rolling back Emmanuel Macron’s pensions reform - France’s Prime Minister François Bayrou has offered to “renegotiate” Emmanuel Macron’s unpopular move to raise workers’ retirement age from 62 to 64, in a bid to win round leftists as he attempts to pass a budget in a hung parliament. Read more
UK councils say government ‘can’t have it both ways’ on pension reform - Councils in England and Wales that manage £145b of assets have hit back at government plans for a series of pension “megafunds”, warning that the pools could leave them on the hook for decisions over which they have little control. Read more
Industry News
Goldman Sachs chief David Solomon questions start-ups’ need to list - Goldman Sachs chief David Solomon has warned private companies to take “great caution” before deciding to go public, adding that the depth of capital in private markets has removed the need for many to list at all. Read more
Trump plans to designate cryptocurrency as a national priority - The order is expected to name crypto as a national imperative or priority — strategic wording intended to guide government agencies to work with the industry. It is also slated to create a crypto advisory council to advocate for the industry’s policy priorities. Read more
Klarna seeks to offload US ‘pay in 4’ loans - Banks including Citigroup, RBC, Nordea and Société Générale are involved in the discussions about the sale. The transaction would help free up capital for loan growth needed to satisfy potential IPO investors, ahead of one of the year’s most hotly anticipated stock market listings. Read more
AI has venture investors excited about (yes) accounting firms - Venture investors believe generative AI technology can make traditional services businesses—especially those heavy on knowledge work, like accounting—more profitable and scalable, so much so, that they become desirable targets for the sky-streaking growth ambitions of venture capitalists. Read more
Saudi listings grab the spotlight in Gulf’s IPO boom - Initial public offerings from Saudi Arabia have been the star performers in a string of recent share sales in the Middle East - the average performance of stocks that listed over the past year in Saudi Arabia has been 37%. According to ratings agency Fitch, Saudi Arabia also has the largest asset management industry in the Gulf Cooperation Council, with over $250b in assets under management as of June 2024. Read more
Americans are tipping less than they have in years - The trend is driven by fatigue over rising prices and growing prompts for tips at places where gratuities haven’t historically been expected. The average tip at full-service restaurants dropped to 19.3% for the three months that ended Sept. 30 and hasn’t budged much since. Read more
Amazon to buy Indian BNPL startup Axio for over $150m - The move by Amazon deepens its push into financial services in one of its fastest-growing markets. Axio, formerly known as Capital Float, specializes in providing credit to self-employed individuals and households at the point of sale on major e-commerce platforms, including Amazon and MakeMyTrip. Read more
Coinbase to offer bitcoin-backed loans - Coinbase (COIN) is adding bitcoin-backed loans to its U.S. product lineup, leaning on Morpho, the largest lending platform on its Base network, to drive eyeballs and wallets to its growing on-chain economy. Borrowers will post sizable amounts of collateral rather than rely on their credit score for access. Read more
Pension funds dabble in crypto after massive bitcoin rally - Pension funds are dipping their toes into buying bitcoin, in a sign that even typically staid corners of finance are finding it hard to ignore the potential outsized returns from cryptocurrencies. Most funds have turned to the regulated US exchange traded funds approved last year, which invest directly in crypto on investors’ behalf and track the price of tokens such as bitcoin and ethereum. Read more
India’s digital payments strategy is cutting out Visa and Mastercard - India’s strategy builds on the Unified Payments Interface, known as UPI, a nine-year-old system that lets consumers and merchants bypass traditional card networks by connecting bank accounts directly through QR codes and phone numbers. Read more
Fidelity Investments introduces Fidelity Stock Transfer, a digital-first stock transfer agent solution - Fidelity Stock Transfer allows users to easily move shares, run reports, and see everything all in one place, giving clients a total portfolio view across all their holdings, from brokerage to stock compensation to retirement savings. Read more
CBRE buys remainder of co-working company Industrious at an $800m valuation - Founded in 2013, New York-based Industrious raised a total of $522m in funding from investors, including Riverwood Capital and Fifth Wall Ventures. The news of its acquisition at the $800m+ valuation is particularly interesting considering that competitor WeWork, once valued at $47b, filed for bankruptcy in November 2023. Read more
Salesforce to launch AI agents and cloud-based POS for retailers - Agentforce for Retail will offer a new library of pre-built agent skills that will help retailers automate things like order management, guided shopping, appointment scheduling and loyalty promotion creation. Retail Cloud with Modern POS will help retailers serve customers online and offline with features like mobile POS and inventory management. Read more
Apple in talks with Barclays, Synchrony to replace Goldman in credit card deal - Several financial firms are vying to replace Goldman, which launched the credit card with Apple in 2019, the sources said. While other lenders are tempted by working with Apple, one of the world's most recognizable brands, they also viewed the original deal terms as risky and unprofitable, sources told Reuters in December 2023. Read more
Retail trading platform eToro files for US IPO and chases $5b valuation - The company, founded in 2007, allows customers to trade assets such as stocks and cryptocurrencies. It managed $11.3b of customer assets across 3m accounts, the FT reported last March. Its progress towards a listing comes as other start-ups stay private for longer, frustrating the hopes of investors and bankers for blockbuster stock market flotations. Read more
FinTech Collective Newsletter
Curated News with Context
Delivered every Monday, the weekly newsletter, produced by our team, provides a tightly edited rundown of global fintech news, along with a bit of our original analysis.